Meghan Markle’s new Netflix series, “With Love, Meghan,” has been met with criticism from podcast host Kinsey Schofield. In an interview with Fox News Digital, Schofield accused Markle of being “self-consumed and tone-deaf” on the show. Schofield pointed out Markle’s interaction with guest Mindy Kaling, saying, “You’re standing next to Mindy Kaling, and you’re not asking her how she built her girl boss empire?
Why?” She urged Markle to “elevate the people around her instead of hijacking all the oxygen in the room.”
The podcast host also criticized Markle’s insistence on being called “Meghan Sussex,” claiming it showed a lack of humility and authenticity. Schofield questioned the genuineness of the connections portrayed on the show, asking, “She’s doing random arts and crafts in someone else’s house with people she claims are her very best friends but doesn’t know that they’re left-handed or allergic to peanut butter?”
Schofield concluded by calling the show a “painful farce,” noting that Markle’s tips and tricks were common knowledge and adding a final jab about wastefulness and trivial activities. The show’s premiere also drew lower viewership compared to Markle’s previous Netflix series, “Harry & Meghan.” According to Samba TV data, “With Love, Meghan” attracted 526,000 households in its first five days, while “Harry & Meghan” garnered 2.1 million households within three days of its release.
Critics skeptical of Meghan’s authenticity
Despite the mixed reviews and modest viewership, Netflix seems content with the show’s performance, with Markle announcing on Instagram that it will return for another season. The series features Markle hosting various celebrities, including Mindy Kaling, Vicky Tsai, Abigail Spencer, Daniel Martin, Tracy Robbins, and Alice Waters, with Prince Harry making an appearance in the final episode.
Critics have pointed out that the show’s repetitive format, Markle’s sometimes overly meticulous nature, and her need for approval and validation can make the series feel tedious and inauthentic. Some have compared her to other lifestyle hosts like Martha Stewart or Ina Garten, noting that Markle either lacks the competence or seems unwilling to share any deep insights. Ultimately, “With Love, Meghan” appears to be more focused on generating meaning and validation for Markle herself rather than offering genuine homemaking tips or moments of fun.
Despite the high production quality and the presence of genuine guests, the series feels constrained and lacks the authentic charm that would truly engage viewers.